Industry insights

Powder-Coated Crowd Control Barriers: What an Adhesion Report Can Tell You

For a bulk order of powder-coated barriers, ask which test was used, what was tested and how the results were classified. A rating without a method and a batch reference is difficult to use at acceptance.

Why Adhesion Is Tested

A powder-coated crowd-control barrier is handled more roughly than almost any other coated product. It is dragged, stacked steel on steel, hooked to its neighbours and leaned on by thousands of people.

The Cross-Cut Test

A lattice of cuts is made through the coating to the substrate with a sharp blade. Loose material is removed, usually with adhesive tape, and the lattice is compared with a classification scale. The spacing of the cuts depends on the coating thickness.

The Substrate

Pre-galvanized tube presents a difficult surface.

Pretreatment

StagePurpose
Mechanical cleaning of weldsRemove spatter, slag and sharp points
Alkaline or neutral degreasingRemove mill oil, forming lubricant and soil
RinseRemove cleaner
Light etch or sweep blastRemove passivation and zinc oxide; give a fine profile
Conversion coatingThin layer that bonds to zinc and to the powder: zinc phosphate, or chromium-free zirconium or titanium based
DryingRemove all water, including from inside tubes and joints

Applying the Test to Barriers

Companion panels: flat test panels of the same substrate, hung on the same jig and processed with the barriers, allow the test to be done properly on every batch. Tests on the product itself are then made at a lower frequency to confirm the panels represent it.

Repair: each test leaves a damaged area that must be touched up, or the test piece scrapped.

Edge Coverage

Molten powder pulls away from sharp edges under surface tension, and electrostatic application tends to under-coat recesses while over-coating outside corners. The film on a sharp edge may be a small fraction of the film on the flat, and that is where corrosion starts.

FeatureProblem
Sawn tube ends and sheared plateSharp arris and burr; film very thin
Mesh wire endsSharp cut ends
Weld spatter and rough weld toesPoints protrude through the film
Inside corners and wire crossingsShielded from powder (Faraday-cage effect)
Hanging pointsBare contact mark

Pull-Off Testing as a Complement

The cross-cut test gives a classification, not a strength. Where a number is needed, for thick films, for comparing pretreatments, or to resolve a dispute, the pull-off test of ISO 4624 or ASTM D4541 is used.

Cure Control

Thermosetting polyester powder must reach a stated metal temperature for a stated time to cross-link fully.

Tube frames and mesh heat at different rates. Thin mesh wire reaches temperature in a few minutes; a heavy base plate or a concrete-filled foot lags far behind. The oven schedule must cure the slowest part without over-baking the fastest. This is established by running a temperature recorder through the oven with probes on the thickest and thinnest sections of a real product, and repeating the run whenever the product mix or line speed changes.

ConditionSymptomsCheck
Under-curePoor impact and flexibility; film softens and marks with solvent; poor adhesion; early chalkingSolvent rub test as the powder supplier specifies; impact or bend test on a test panel
Over-bakeYellowing or colour shift, loss of gloss, brittlenessColour and gloss against reference
Uneven cureSome parts pass, others fail on the same loadOven temperature profile with probes on product

The Coating System on a Barrier

Failure locationAppearance after the test
Between powder and zinc (adhesive failure)Bright zinc exposed; back of the flake is smooth
Within the powder (cohesive failure)Powder remains on both the part and the flake
Between zinc and steelBare steel exposed; zinc on the back of the flake
Within a zinc corrosion layerWhite powdery layer under the coating

Acceptance and Frequency

Every result should be recorded with the powder batch, the pretreatment bath records and the oven profile for that load.

Wet Adhesion

Powder on zinc can show perfect dry adhesion and still fail in service, because moisture diffusing through the film attacks a poorly prepared zinc surface. A wet adhesion test exposes this.

Hold a batch when the report and sample do not match

If a report identifies a flat test coupon but several delivered barriers show peeling at the hooks, record both findings. Set the affected lot aside and ask for a check on the actual parts and coating batch. Release the lot only against the agreed criteria and a recorded disposition.

Compare like-for-like test reports

Record the exact standard and edition in the order. ISO 2409 and ASTM D3359 use distinct methods and rating schemes. Compare offers using the same method, substrate, coating system and conditioning. Ask for the classification, the layer where separation occurred and the link to the delivered coating batch.

Frequently asked questions

What does a powder coating adhesion report show?

It records how the tested coating on the identified substrate performed in the specified test. Match the method and sample to the order before accepting the result.

Can I use a test on a flat coupon to accept coated barrier welds?

Check whether the coupon represents the substrate and finish in the order. Inspect the finished barrier, including welds and edges, against the agreed criteria.

Related product and planning information
Steel crowd control barriers · Quality control

Further reading · ISO 2409:2020, Paints and varnishes — Cross-cut test. ASTM D3359-23, Standard Test Methods for Rating Adhesion by Tape Test.

Share this article